New gimbal movement?

[rrohde]

Question for those in the know:

How does the new gimbal-based sticks (e.g., Mamba MkIII, Gunfighter, etc) move in terms of smooth, circular movement? Is it perfectly smooth and round like the Thrustmaster Warthog stick, or more like the CH Products Fighterstick, which moves more angular (e.g., feeling the "notches" when rotating the stick in a circle; feeling the axis transitions) because of the way it is built?

This question came up on the DCS forum in an unrelated discussion, and I was wondering this myself...

Thanks.

[Bourrinopathe]

Good question! I can't wait to test that myself.
Based on the design and the goals it should be close to a smooth circle, even near the center (with the soft center cams). The progressive resistance should provide a very interesting feeling and a precious mechanical feedback about the angular limits (and thus the aircraft capabilities).

Unless I'm mistaken, the prototype picture shows the two cam versions (soft center on the left and firm center on the right)
(I know the pitch axis cam design is specific to the stick centermass (slightly pushing to the front) - so I might be wrong):


On a related note:
I'd love to know how a Su-27 control stick feels. Even if the distance between the gimbal and the stick itself is far more important than with the classic Mamba stick.

[UIV]

Good question! I can't wait to test that myself.
Based on the design and the goals it should be close to a smooth circle, even near the center (with the soft center cams). The progressive resistance should provide a very interesting feeling and a precious mechanical feedback about the angular limits (and thus the aircraft capabilities).

Unless I'm mistaken, the prototype picture shows the two cam versions (soft center on the left and firm center on the right)
(I know the pitch axis cam design is specific to the stick centermass (slightly pushing to the front) - so I might be wrong):


On a related note:
I'd love to know how a Su-27 control stick feels. Even if the distance between the gimbal and the stick itself is far more important than with the classic Mamba stick.

You are right. It's two different cam (soft and hard center detend)

[rrohde]

Thanks for the feedback, Bourrinopathe! Progressive resistance and two types of centering cam options is going to be nice!

@UIV - can you answer the question? How does the new gimbal movement feel? Is it like the Warthog, or like the CH Fighterstick?

[StarLordRick]

Smooth center is what im looking for since i hate how my cougar center works and cant wait my guns on anything for WW2 or space sims.

[Azurith]

Soft center for space sims Fo Sho. Is it gonna come with both? I was under the impression we would get different springs but different cams is pretty slick

[rrohde]

Agreed. Smooth center all the way!

[UIV]

Thanks for the feedback, Bourrinopathe! Progressive resistance and two types of centering cam options is going to be nice!

@UIV - can you answer the question? How does the new gimbal movement feel? Is it like the Warthog, or like the CH Fighterstick?

It's not easy to explain taste of pie if you never eat pie.
I create 2 sets of cam, with different shape to get different feeling. Special cam for Warthog grip is created too. I hope, the combination of different cams and springs can help you to make what feeling of joystick you want.

[Spiftastic]

Thanks for the feedback, Bourrinopathe! Progressive resistance and two types of centering cam options is going to be nice!

@UIV - can you answer the question? How does the new gimbal movement feel? Is it like the Warthog, or like the CH Fighterstick?

It's not easy to explain taste of pie if you never eat pie.
I create 2 sets of cam, with different shape to get different feeling. Special cam for Warthog grip is created too. I hope, the combination of different cams and springs can help you to make what feeling of joystick you want.

Are you saying that the joystick will ship with interchangeable sets of cams, or are they are sold separately?

[rrohde]

Thanks for the feedback, Bourrinopathe! Progressive resistance and two types of centering cam options is going to be nice!

@UIV - can you answer the question? How does the new gimbal movement feel? Is it like the Warthog, or like the CH Fighterstick?

It's not easy to explain taste of pie if you never eat pie.
I create 2 sets of cam, with different shape to get different feeling. Special cam for Warthog grip is created too. I hope, the combination of different cams and springs can help you to make what feeling of joystick you want.

Thanks for the info, UIV! I am looking forward to my Mamba and cannot wait to test this for myself!

[rrohde]

Are you saying that the joystick will ship with interchangeable sets of cams, or are they are sold separately?

That's a good question. I've noticed that the VKB Stick Extension comes with a new set of (probably) stiffer springs, but I haven't seen any cams on sale. So I assume that the Mamba comes with both a soft center and indented center cam - similar to how you can flip the cam over in the VKB T-Rudder pedals (without having to spend extra money).

I hope that UIV can confirm this.

[UIV]

All cams are included in gimbal. No need to buy them separately, as we try to give our clients better choice. We are not Saitek

[rrohde]

That's fantastic, UIV! Thanks for the info!

[Satyrn]

All cams are included in gimbal. No need to buy them separately, as we try to give our clients better choice. We are not Saitek

That is awesome. You really made my day just now.

[Caillin]

We are not Saitek

Quote of the year

Looking forward to seeing the new gimbal in action.